Thursday 19 November

PUBLISHED BY:

WRITTEN BY:

Mduduzi Nkosi


Earlier this year, we were again confronted with the recurring issue of unplaced learners and those placed in schools far from their homes. At the time of writing, about 1000 pupils remain unplaced in Gauteng alone.

This problem has been a commonplace in South Africa’s urban provinces for more than a decade. The fact that we have to content with the same issue for such a long time points to government’s failure to plan, and to an environment where realisation of the right to basic education stands on shaky ground. School admission issues are a direct result of having too many pupils and not enough schools to accommodate them. It should go without saying that the solution lies in building more schools and equipping them to teach more learners.

Migration and population and impact on schooling

School admission challenges are more pronounced in some parts of the country than in others. Internal and international migration onto South Africa’s urban centres is one reason for this. For example, Gauteng and the Western Cape are consistently seeing scores of people move in to seek economic opportunities, many of whom bring children with them, and this is not a new trend.

Rural-urban migration is a reality globally and, in South Africa, predates 1994. If we have, for a long time now, known that population growth in urban areas is to be expected, why are we failing to plan schooling around that growth? The answer lies in how we budget for urban populations. Populations continue to grow in many parts of the country. Gauteng alone recorded net migration of over 1.8 million people in the same period, according to StatsSA data. Yet, public services have not expanded commensurately to meet the increasing demand for schooling that accompanies this growth.

Persistent stories of unplaced learners in schools are a bellwether for a system that is failing to keep up with demand and is not built to provide equal access for everyone. To turn this around, we need to examine how we spend money on building schools.

Fiscal policy and role in infrastructure provisioning

Currently, South Africa is building a system of conditional grant funding at the provincial level. Urban provinces tend to spend 100% of their allocation of this money every fiscal year, signaling both a need and an appetite for new and improved schools. Nationally raised revenue is the source for funding for the conditional grants. Thus, the national Budget in February serves as a key lever for improving and expanding access for all, but improvement to the system does not stop there.

In the education sector, the Education Infrastructure Grand (EIG) and School Backlogs Infrastructure Grant (SIBG) fund school infrastructure programmes. The two are due to be merged this year as part of the rationalisations in the education budget. Of concern with these grants is the delivery and the outcomes they have achieved for education infrastructure.

The pace at which schools are being built has not kept pace with the demand of space for learners in many parts of the country, yet billions are spent each year. An example of this is the education department’s report that only one new school was built last year with SIBG funding, far below the sector’s needs. For a budget of R15 billion for both maintenance and new construction, the delivery of only one school is unacceptable, especially given the average spending rates for well above 98% for the grants.

Build more and build quicker

To break the cycle of learners struggling to find placement in schools, we have to build more schools close to where they live. Addressing capacity constraints in schools requires going beyond the status quo and building new infrastructure at a rate far exceeding what we are doing now.

That requires to things: first, the upcoming combined grant for school infrastructure cannot be lower that the sum of both EIG and SIBG at their peak allocations. Secondly, provinces that receive funds to build schools must do so more efficiently and quickly. The sector thus needs both additional budget allocations and demonstrable improvements in delivery efficiency and outcomes in tandem. A learner who has to travel more than 15km to get to a school is an indication that more ought to be done to improve access for all.

School infrastructure is economic infrastructure

School infrastructure should be treated with the same sense of urgency as economic infrastructure. The mooted R1 trillion in infrastructure investment should include a sizeable investment in school infrastructure. Infrastructure investment without much improvement in the places where people learn is an exercise in futility. Improving schools makes the gains from economic infrastructure much more far-reaching and meaningful. An educated population can make better use of opportunities that come with improved economic infrastructure. National policy must recognise this and make it part of its strategic core.

Investment in new schools is the only way to solve the ever-recurring school admissions problem. It is an essential part of building a country where all who live in it can thrive and live to their fullest potential. Prioritising schools as a core component of the “war on poverty” will go a long way towards the state’s current efforts to ensure that we build a South Africa that works for everyone. Wednesday’s budget is an ample opportunity to get the ball rolling.

Mduduzi Nkosi is a budget researcher at SECTION27 and is a member of the Budget Justice Coalition.


0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *