For immediate release
1 October 2018
Civil society organisations call on the South African government to end austerity measures and intensify its efforts to combat poverty and inequality.
- South Africa presents its first compliance report to the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
- In order to meet its human rights obligations, the South African State should adopt a human rights-based approach to fiscal and economic policy, take all necessary steps to tackle corruption and increase funding for healthcare and education and address disparities between groups.
Johannesburg / New York, 10/01/2018— SECTION27, the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ), and the Center for Economic and Social Rights (CESR) argue in a to the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights that austerity policies are undermining human rights in South Africa (see a summary fact sheet ). The organisations urge the South African government to roll back these measures and instead pursue fairer economic alternatives in compliance with its human rights obligations.
The submission is made on the occasion of South Africa’s first appearance before the Committee on the implementation of its obligations in terms of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, taking place in Geneva this week. The Covenant closely mirrors the social and economic rights guaranteed in the South African Constitution.
Despite the more inclusive economic and social agenda initiated by South Africa’s democratic government after 1994, enjoyment of the rights laid out in the Covenant and Constitution remains elusive for the majority of people.
Austerity measures in the context of extreme inequality present a grave threat to economic, social and cultural rights
South African government expenditure per person has declined for three years in a row. Since 2016/17, the growth of non-interest budget expenditure – essentially expenditure on social and economic programmes – has averaged at 0.3%, below average population growth (at 1.6%), and average GDP growth (at 1.2%). This year government increased the value-added tax from 14 to 15 percent. This disproportionately impacts poorer households, reducing their disposable income and potentially increasing levels of poverty.
The acceleration of austerity comes in response to pressure from credit rating agencies, public panic over public debt levels, and lower than expected GDP growth and revenue collection. However, the country’s debt levels, projected to peak at 56.2 percent during 2021/22 and 2022/23, are similar to those of other emerging markets (projected to reach, on average, 57.6 percent in 2023) and lower than most developed countries (where debt averaged at 105.4 percent of GDP in 2017).
Widespread corruption and ‘state capture’ during the Jacob Zuma administration has reduced revenue collection, undermined social service delivery, and led to increased debt and severe mismanagement of critical state-owned enterprises. In many cases ‘state capture’ has allowed for the ‘repurposing’ of state institutions at all levels to become vehicles of enrichment rather than service delivery. The economy continues to flounder due to long-standing structural weaknesses. Austerity policies do nothing to address the underlying causes of these problems.
Instead, systemic inequality and widespread poverty persist. Nearly 50 percent of the country lives below the poverty line. Unemployment levels are over 30 percent. And the wealthiest one percent owns half of all assets in the country. In this context – where huge numbers of people rely on government services and support simply to survive – cutting government spending on social programs and services will be catastrophic for economic, social and cultural rights.
Avoidable resource shortfalls are leading to violations of the rights to health and education.
The realisation of these rights, including the rights to health and education, is already being undermined by austerity.
The health system is in crisis.
- In recent years – with 80 percent of the population uninsured and the health system heavily overburdened – health expenditure per uninsured person has declined.
- Due to limits on personnel expenditure, most provinces suffer from chronic staff shortages eroding the quality of care available to the most marginalised communities and resulted in huge medico-legal bills.
- Although government estimates it would need to spend about seven percent more a year until 2025 to arrive at its National Health Insurance objectives, real spending on health last year declined slightly.
Education is faring no better.
- Real spending per pupil has decreased over the last decade across all provinces.
- Funding cuts to much needed school infrastructure programmes and underfunding of the country’s poorest schools have left many schools in dire conditions.
- Nearly 40 percent of schools have no library.
- Children have died as a result of poor school infrastructure; Lumka Mthethwa and Michael Komape drowned in broken school pit latrines.
All of these cuts have reinforced and amplified long-standing apartheid-era inequalities in health and education.
There are alternatives to austerity
Progressive tax reform and tackling corruption are alternatives to austerity that can help South Africa fulfil its human rights obligations. Although South Africa’s current tax system is progressive, it needs to be much more so given the depth of inequality in the country.
- Personal income rates for the top earners have decreased over the last two decades.
- Tax breaks for high-income earners cost over 52 billion Rand in 2015/2016.
- Corporate tax rates are amongst the lowest in emerging markets.
- Wealth is significantly under-taxed.
- Trillions of rand have been lost to tax evasion and other types of illicit financial flows over the last decade.
Alongside tax, billions of Rand a year are estimated to be lost each year through corruption. Last year, irregular, wasteful and unauthorised expenditure amounted to nearly 50 billion Rand – more than the total budget shortfall.
South Africa must maximise the availability of resources and ensure the realisation of rights
The Covenant commits South Africa to maximising the resources available for the fulfilment of rights. In line with this commitment, South Africa must take immediate action to increase spending on essential public services. South Africa should explore fairer methods of taxation that result in greater redistribution and enable a shift towards the people-centred, rights-based development envisaged in the Constitution.
As civil society organisations we call on the South African government to reverse its austerity policies and take immediate action to fulfil its constitutional and international obligations and ensure the realisation of socio-economic rights.
For further information contact:
Nomatter Ndebele, SECTION27, Johannesburg, , +27 72 919 2752.
Terry Roethlein, CESR, New York, , +1 718 237 9145.